Ecclesiastes 1:17 - Exposition

And I gave my heart . He reiterates the expression in order to emphasize his earnestness and energy in the pursuit of wisdom. And knowing, as St. Jerome says, that "contrariis contraria inteiliguntur," he studies the opposite of wisdom, and learns the truth by contrasting it with error. And to know madness and folly ( Ecclesiastes 2:12 ). The former word, holeloth (intensive plural), by its etymology points to a confusion of thought, i . e . an unwisdom which deranges all ideas of order and propriety; and folly (here sikluth ), throughout the sapiential books, is identified with vice and wickedness, the contradictory of practical godliness. The LXX . has παραβολὰς καὶ ἐπιστήμην , "parables and knowledge," and some editors have altered the Hebrew text in accordance with this version, which they consider more suitable to the context. But Koheleth's standpoint is quite consistent. To use the words of St. Jerome in his 'Commentary,' " AE qualis studii fuit Salomoni, scire sapientiam et scientiam, et e regione errores et stultitiam, ut in aliis appetendis et aliis declinandis vera ejus sapientia probaretur." On the other hand, Den-Sirs gives a much-needed warning against touching pitch (Ecclesiasticus 13:1), and argues expressly that "the knowledge of wickedness is not wisdom" (Ecclesiasticus 19:22). Plumptre unnecessarily sees in the use of the term" madness 'an echo of the teaching of the Stoics, who regarded men's weaknesses as forms of insanity. The moralist had no need to travel beyond his own experience in order to learn that sin was the acme of unwisdom, a declension from reason which might well be called madness. The subject is handled by Cicero, 'Tusc. Disput.,' 3.4, 5. We are reminded of Horace's expression ('Carm.,' 2.7. 27)—

"Recepto Dulce mihi furere est amico."

And Anacreon's (31.), θέλω θέλω μανῆναι . Thus far we have had Koheleth's secret thoughts—what he communed with his own heart ( Ecclesiastes 1:16 ). The result of his studies was most unsatisfying I perceived that this also is vexation of spirit ; or, a striving after wind , as Ecclesiastes 1:14 Though the word is somewhat different. As such labor is wasted, for man cannot control issues.